Monday, March 05, 2007

Feminist conversations


Over at I Blame the Patriarchy, folks are reading Shulamith Firestone's book The Dialectic of Sex (1969, written when she was 25). It's not a perfect book, parts of it are dated and wrong--but it was so daring, and is still so thought-provoking that I am loving the discussion folks are having about it.
I just got my copy of The Nation, and the cover features Ruth Rosen's extremely good article The Care Crisis:How Women are Bearing the Burden of a National Emergency. It says a lot of importantthings about the structural inequalities that grind women down, and recommends real groups and actions, steps people could make in the current political sphere to make a huge difference. It's a really astute article. She's trying to appeal on a pragmatic level to US citizens in the hopes that we'll try to reframe the national political discussion around policy reforms. But it is trying to appeal to the good will of liberals--not a bad thing in and of itself, just not enough. Do I mean she's wrong or she doesn't get it? Not at all--she's adopting an important rhetorical strategy of seeking to move her readers to action, rather than articulate a theory. For the radical discussion, hop over to Twisty's to check out the Shulamith Firestone book club, where B. Dagger Lee is rockin' the house.
Professor Zero linked to Feminist-reprise where Amy's Brain Today put up this wonderful passage by Joanna Russ. Thank you, PZ, Amy, and everyone sharing your thoughts today.
Here are the words of mi tocaya

"...it can certainly be objected, although women's work as wives and mothers is not paid for with money, it is nonetheless recompensed in another, quite obvious way. Women are, after all, supported by their husbands. All women? Not quite. After all, the family wage was never available to the majority of women who were married to working men. Only those women married to middle-management men or the labor aristocracy benefit from it. In fact, it never affected most working men or the women married to them and it still doesn't. It is, in fact, becoming less and less of a reality all the time. Indeed, we have reached a point (at least in industrialized countries like the United States, Canada and Britain) where "women's work" is being required of most women in addition to paid work--at which women are being underpaid on the grounds that they're being "supported" by the very husbands who aren't doing so because they can't do so...

Nor is the marriage contract one into which just any two people can enter, nor can six or eight people enter into it, nor can those who enter into it change its legal provisions to just anything they like. For example, men may not marry men nor women, women (we are fighting over that right now, a fight that would have been inconceivable thirty years ago), nor can I marry you with the legal requirement that you balance a grapefruit on your head every morning to amuse me at breakfast and then divorce you when you don't, on those grounds alone. (That is a "personal" matter only, like the standard of living provided by a husband to a wife, over which the laws have no say.) Nor is it legal, in any other contract, to require that your employee allow you to fuck her...Such a tangle of the personal, the state-run, and the customary is the institution of marriage that it resembles no other work contract in capitalist society. Instead, marriage--which is certainly the key institution of the patriarchal mode of production--strongly resembles the feudal system of exploitation and oppression that existed in Europe before capitalism arose.

The situations of a woman in Western European/North American society today and that of a peasant in Europe in, say, the tenth century, show some striking similarities. For example, a woman enters the labor pool for certain jobs (among them the job of wife and mother) by being born into a certain group, her sex, just as peasants were peasants and nobles noble, and peasants did peasants' work because they were born to it. Her job as wife and mother is the result not of an impersonal money contract but of a personal relationship, as were the relations between monarchs and subjects, liege lords and vassals. Her status (insofar as it's the result of her sex) is an ascribed one, that is, one into which she was born, just as medieval European peasants were peasants and nobles nobles because their daddies were, and that status has, as it had in feudal social systems, the most far-reaching and marked results on her sexuality, her dress, her manner, her gait, her appearance, the way others treat her, her immunity from or susceptibility to violence and her freedom, wealth, health, and the amount and kind of her work.

If the feudal, personal relations between lord and peasant were a matter of exploitation and oppression--which of course they were--and if they produced wealth for one class at the expense of the other--which they most certainly did, by giving the one class control over the unrecompensed work of the other class--then I see no bar against applying similar terms to the patriarchal organization of production, which includes reproduction. If we do this, we are led, I think, to the inescapable conclusion that feminism is the study of the patriarchal system of unrecompensed labor and the politics and propaganda that maintain it."


______
From "Is Labor Labor?" in What Are We Fighting For? Sex, Race, Class, and the Future of Feminism by Joanna Russ (St. Martin's Press, 1998)

No comments: